Project Marks

The following table provides a quick guide to your marks so far this semester. The brief comments relate to your major deliverables, i.e., minisites 1 & 2. For more information about the breakdown of marks and the assessment see below.

Legend

P1: Presentation 1 (5%)
M1: Minisite 1 (20%)
M2: Minisite 2 (20%)
P2: Presentation 2 (5%)

Individual Project Marks Sorted by Student ID

Student ID	P1	M1	M2	P2	Comments
200116683	100%	98%	92%	---	Great idea. Excellent documentation.	Some danger of original idea being diluted as features creep in.
306133962	100%	58%	62%	---	Good research of users and requirements	No process documentation (blog). Ironic web design?
306134608	40%	81%	79%	---	Very good use of scenarios to describe the idea.	Application idea is a bit too broad, try to focus it.
306141418	60%	---	---	---
306151405	80%	65%	59%	---	Good use of design template, nice writing style.	Documentation is far too brief in all areas.
306209055	80%	88%	62%	---	Good initial idea.	Sadly, development of idea between minisites is unfocussed.
306210649	100%	99%	91%	---	Interesting idea. Good first minisite. Well documented.	Process documentation (blog) stopped, which is a shame...
307139530	80%	79%	81%	---	Strong concept. Well designed web site. Clear documentation.	More research into similar ideas could have provided inspiration.
307140059	80%	92%	98%	---	Good research to support far-fetched concept.	Confused ideas about potential user group. More research needed?
307140857	60%	75%	85%	---	Useful application ideas, appropriate to iPhone.	Strange initial choice of potential user group.
307141594	60%	72%	65%	---	Good documentation of process and initial idea.	Development of idea reasonable but could be pushed much further.
307146413	80%	71%	69%	---	Recommender system is a good idea for the iPhone.	Minisites need more written content. Multimedia platform specific.
307153665	80%	75%	65%	---	Good idea. Well documented of idea and process.	Is the aesthetic of your 2nd mini site appropriate?
307156087	100%	58%	52%	---	Good idea, good documentation of data gathering.	Documentation of original idea lacking. Web site was broken.
307164454	60%	78%	72%	---	Excellent use of multimedia to document idea.	More background research should be in documentation.
307165760	80%	79%	81%	---	Excellent initial idea for application.	Some problems with design/layout of web site detract from content.
307165787	100%	78%	82%	---	Great application idea. Good mini site design.	Initial analysis of user requirements a little confused.
307165922	60%	69%	71%	---	Basic concept is very strong. Some good web design.	Lack of analysis of research. Interface far too crowded.
307166775	60%	61%	59%	---	A good application idea.	Concept should have been developed much further.
307167992	60%	63%	67%	---	Attractive minisites. Interesting concept.	Application interface should be tailored more towards iPhone.
307169006	80%	83%	87%	---	Great concept for a location based game.	Some presentation issues with original web site.
307171760	80%	79%	71%	---	Great game ideas that really work with iPhone.	Need better description of how feedback has affected redesign.
307177602	80%	68%	72%	---	Far-fetched concept. :-) Nice ideas for initial minisite.	Background research should have been better documented.
307185478	40%	69%	69%	---	Good research to back up design process.	Documentation of ideas a little sparse, more info/thought needed.
307187004	80%	97%	98%	---	Very good development and presentation of ideas.
307189317	100%	91%	99%	---	Ambitious idea. Excellent documentation.
307191303	100%	77%	73%	---	Very good web design. Idea fits well with iPhone.	Design of application needs more work.
307195392	60%	79%	61%	---	Consistent design, well-matched to concept.	More research needed to develop ideas further.
307198235	60%	78%	82%	---	Nice idea. Good analysis of feedback from users.	Some more research about similar devices would be good.
307199258	60%	78%	62%	---	Challenging idea, requiring research of user group.	More documentation of process and analysis of user feedback needed.
307200388	60%	71%	69%	---	Use of Flash OK but small window is problematic.	No process documentation (blog)!
307203158	80%	79%	81%	---	Good documentation of initial idea & analysis of feedback.	Documentation of process has slooowed down... shame.
307204006	60%	89%	91%	---	Very well documented. Excellent design process.
307204367	100%	82%	78%	---	Provocative game idea. Good user requirements gathering.	Wed sites and hi-fi prototype should reflect aesthetics of game.
307207536	60%	75%	55%	---	Great game idea for iPhone.	Very little development evident between minisites.
307216764	60%	78%	72%	---	Great minisites. Good user feedback analysis.	Shame the blogging of the process stopped.
307216926	80%	---	---	---
307220575	80%	77%	73%	---	Good work getting feedback from potential users.	Process documentation (blog) ended back in August.

Assessment

Milestones / Deliverables

The following table provides a breakdown of the grading system according to the various deliverables that must be completed during the semester.

	Value	Comment
Presentation 1	5%	Presentation of initial idea for iPhone application.
Minisite 1	20%	Web site documenting initial design idea, prototype and feedback from users.
Minisite 2	20%	Web site documenting revised design and results from prototyping it with potential users.
Presentation 2	5%	Presentation of on-going design process to be given in the second half of the semester.
Final Website	50%	Web site presenting final design idea as a completed product.

Grading System

The following table provides a breakdown of grading system according to the activities required for each deliverable. Each deliverable should show some evidence of each of the following, although they are assessed differently between minisites and presentations.

	Value	Comment
Research	20%	Research the problem, research the technology, research other Web 2.0 applications for the iPhone.
Design	20%	Design of the look and feel of your application and your website is a major factor in your assessment.
Process	20%	Document your design process and your reflections on your blog. This will include blogging about class.
Documentation	40%	Document your design on your product website(s). This will include the use of video and audio.